SEE LATEST ESSAYS Public law essays

How effectively can Parliament and the courts control executive power?

Law Writer
October 19, 2026
No comments
Public law - photo of the houses of parliament

This essay is a sample of our Basic AI essay writer (Undergraduate 2:2 standard).

For guaranteed 2:1, First Class and Masters-level essays, register and top up your wallet.

This essay will evaluate the effectiveness of parliamentary and judicial controls over executive power, with a specific focus on the royal prerogative. The royal prerogative, consisting of powers once held by the monarch but now largely exercised by government ministers, represents a significant source of executive authority operating outside of statute. This analysis will argue that while judicial control over the prerogative has expanded considerably, creating important checks on the executive, significant areas, particularly those concerning ‘high policy’, remain subject to limited accountability. This suggests that placing major prerogative powers on a statutory footing may be necessary to enhance democratic legitimacy.

The traditional role of the courts was limited to determining the existence and scope of a prerogative power, not how it was used. The courts can rule that a claimed prerogative does not exist, but they cannot create new ones (BBC v Johns, 1965). The primary control has long been the principle of parliamentary sovereignty, confirmed in *Attorney-General v De Keyser’s Royal Hotel Ltd* (1920). This case established that where Parliament has legislated on a matter previously governed by the prerogative, the statute takes precedence, and the prerogative power is placed in abeyance. This ensures the executive cannot use the prerogative to circumvent the will of Parliament as expressed in legislation. This principle was reinforced in *R v Secretary of State for the Home Department, ex parte Fire Brigades Union* (1995), where the House of Lords prevented the Home Secretary from using the prerogative to introduce a scheme that was contrary to an unimplemented statutory provision. These cases show the courts’ vital role in upholding the constitutional hierarchy between statute and prerogative.

A major development in judicial control came with *Council of Civil Service Unions v Minister for the Civil Service* (the *GCHQ* case) (1985). The House of Lords held that the *exercise* of a prerogative power could be subject to judicial review on the same grounds as a statutory power, such as illegality or procedural impropriety. This opened the door to greater judicial scrutiny. However, Lord Roskill noted in his judgment that some prerogative powers, by their nature, were not justiciable. These ‘excluded categories’ included matters of high policy like the making of treaties, the defence of the realm, and the dissolution of Parliament. Therefore, while *GCHQ* was a landmark step, it left a significant accountability deficit for the most politically important prerogative powers.

Recent Supreme Court judgments have challenged the boundaries of justiciability. In *R (Miller) v Secretary of State for Exiting the European Union* (2017), the court ruled that the government could not use the prerogative to trigger Article 50 of the Treaty on European Union. It reasoned that doing so would frustrate the purpose of the European Communities Act 1972 and remove statutory rights without Parliament’s consent, reaffirming the *De Keyser* principle in a modern constitutional context. Even more significantly, in *R (Miller) v The Prime Minister* and *Cherry v Advocate General for Scotland* (2019), the court held that the Prime Minister’s advice to the Queen to prorogue Parliament was justiciable and unlawful. The court reasoned that the prorogation was unlawful because it had the effect of frustrating or preventing the ability of Parliament to carry out its constitutional functions without a reasonable justification. This decision demonstrated a new judicial willingness to intervene to protect fundamental constitutional principles, even in an area previously considered to be pure politics.

Despite these judicial advances, parliamentary and judicial controls remain imperfect. For major powers like deploying armed forces or making treaties, accountability is often political rather than legal. The Ponsonby Rule, a convention requiring treaties to be laid before Parliament, was given statutory footing by the Constitutional Reform and Governance Act 2010, but Parliament can only refuse to ratify a treaty, not amend it. Similarly, the convention that Parliament should debate military action is not legally binding. These arrangements provide some political scrutiny but fall short of full democratic control.

In conclusion, the courts have become significantly more effective at controlling prerogative powers, moving from only questioning their existence to reviewing their exercise and protecting parliamentary sovereignty from their use. The *Miller* cases show a judiciary willing to enforce constitutional principles against the executive. However, gaps in democratic accountability persist, especially concerning high-policy matters like military action. Placing such powers on a statutory footing would provide a clearer legal framework and strengthen parliamentary control, aligning their use more closely with democratic principles. While this may reduce executive flexibility, the gain in accountability and legitimacy would be a worthwhile constitutional reform.

References

  • Attorney-General v De Keyser’s Royal Hotel Ltd [1920] AC 508.
  • BBC v Johns (Inspector of Taxes) [1965] Ch 32.
  • Constitutional Reform and Governance Act 2010.
  • Council of Civil Service Unions v Minister for the Civil Service [1985] AC 374.
  • R (Miller) v Secretary of State for Exiting the European Union [2017] UKSC 5.
  • R (Miller) v The Prime Minister; Cherry v Advocate General for Scotland [2019] UKSC 41.
  • R v Secretary of State for the Home Department, ex parte Fire Brigades Union [1995] 2 AC 513.

Rate this essay:

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating 0 / 5. Vote count: 0

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.

Written By

Law Writer

Recent essays:

Advice for Mick regarding his rights under the Sale of Goods Act 1893

This advice will address the legal position of Mick concerning his purchase of a Ford Fiesta from Dodgy Derek, a car dealer. The central ...
Read more: Advice for Mick regarding his rights under the Sale of Goods Act 1893

Gillespie and Weare note that ‘Statutes are Acts of Parliament and are either Public Acts … or Private Acts …’. Explain what a Public Act is and explain what a Private Act is and identify two examples of each of these two types of Primary Legislation. One of the identified examples of a Public Act should be one that was enacted in the twentieth century and the other should be one that was enacted in the twenty first century. One of the identified examples of a Private Act should be one that was enacted in the twentieth century and the other should be one that was enacted in the twenty first century. Select one Public Act that was passed using the Parliament Acts (of 1911 and 1949). Analyse the intention of the House of Commons in relation to the key aim to be achieved by the enactment of the Act that you have selected. Note: The Act that you select should be a different one from the two identified examples referred to in the paragraph above.

This assignment will explain the two main types of primary legislation enacted by the Parliament of the United Kingdom, which are Public Acts and ...
Read more: Gillespie and Weare note that ‘Statutes are Acts of Parliament and are either Public Acts … or Private Acts …’. Explain what a Public Act is and explain what a Private Act is and identify two examples of each of these two types of Primary Legislation. One of the identified examples of a Public Act should be one that was enacted in the twentieth century and the other should be one that was enacted in the twenty first century. One of the identified examples of a Private Act should be one that was enacted in the twentieth century and the other should be one that was enacted in the twenty first century. Select one Public Act that was passed using the Parliament Acts (of 1911 and 1949). Analyse the intention of the House of Commons in relation to the key aim to be achieved by the enactment of the Act that you have selected. Note: The Act that you select should be a different one from the two identified examples referred to in the paragraph above.

Permission to approach the inbox?

Helpful legal writing guidance, AI updates, free credits and exclusive offers, delivered occasionally and respectfully. No spam, no waffle, no abuse of process.