Original essay question / assignment brief
Gillespie and Weare note that ‘Statutes are Acts of Parliament and are either Public Acts … or Private Acts …’. Explain what a Public Act is and explain what a Private Act is and identify two examples of each of these two types of Primary Legislation. One of the identified examples of a Public Act should be one that was enacted in the twentieth century and the other should be one that was enacted in the twenty first century. One of the identified examples of a Private Act should be one that was enacted in the twentieth century and the other should be one that was enacted in the twenty first century. Select one Public Act that was passed using the Parliament Acts (of 1911 and 1949). Analyse the intention of the House of Commons in relation to the key aim to be achieved by the enactment of the Act that you have selected. Note: The Act that you select should be a different one from the two identified examples referred to in the paragraph above.
This assignment will explain the two main types of primary legislation enacted by the Parliament of the United Kingdom, which are Public Acts and Private Acts. It will explain what a Public Act is and provide an example from the twentieth century and an example from the twenty first century. It will then explain what a Private Act is and provide an example from the twentieth century and an example from the twenty first century.
Following this, the assignment will select a Public Act that was passed into law using the specific legislative procedure contained within the Parliament Acts of 1911 and 1949. This Act will be a different Act from the examples previously identified. The assignment will then analyse the principal intention that the House of Commons sought to achieve through the enactment of this particular piece of legislation.
Public Acts and Private Acts
Primary legislation in the United Kingdom, also known as an Act of Parliament or a statute, is categorised according to its scope and subject matter. The most common form of primary legislation is the Public Act. A less common but distinct form is the Private Act. The parliamentary procedure for passing each type of Act is different, reflecting their different purposes.
A Public Act is a statute that relates to matters of public policy and has a general effect, applying to the whole country or a significant part of it (Bradley, Ewing and Knight, 2018). The great majority of Acts passed by Parliament each year are Public Acts. They are introduced into Parliament by a Government minister as a Government Bill or by an individual Member of Parliament as a Private Member’s Bill. The purpose of a Public Act is to change the law as it applies to the general population.
One identified example of a Public Act that was enacted in the twentieth century is the Human Rights Act 1998. This Act was passed to incorporate rights and freedoms from the European Convention on Human Rights into domestic UK law. One identified example of a Public Act that was enacted in the twenty first century is the Equality Act 2010. This Act consolidated and strengthened previous anti-discrimination legislation, providing a legal framework to protect the rights of individuals and advance equality of opportunity for all.
In contrast, a Private Act is a form of legislation that has a specific, local, or personal effect. It is intended to grant special powers or exemptions from the general law to a particular person, group of people, or a specific corporate body such as a local authority or a private company (Loveland, 2021). A Private Act is initiated by a petition to Parliament from the outside individuals or bodies, known as the ‘promoters’ of the bill, who will be affected by its provisions. Its application is therefore limited and does not extend to the general public.
One identified example of a Private Act that was enacted in the twentieth century is the University College London Act 1996. The purpose of this Act was to unite a number of medical schools, including the Royal Free Hospital School of Medicine, with University College London. One identified example of a Private Act that was enacted in the twenty first century is the Highgate Cemetery Act 2022. This Act conferred new powers upon the charity which runs Highgate Cemetery for its management and preservation, including the power to extinguish rights of burial in certain circumstances to create new burial space.
The Intention of the House of Commons and the Hunting Act 2004
The Parliament Acts of 1911 and 1949 provide a mechanism by which the House of Commons can pass a Public Act without the consent of the House of Lords. The 1911 Act removed the Lords’ power of absolute veto and replaced it with a power of delay, while the 1949 Act, itself passed using the 1911 Act procedure, further reduced this delaying power. A Public Act that was passed using this procedure is the Hunting Act 2004. This Act is different from the Public Act examples identified in the section above.
The key aim to be achieved by the enactment of the Hunting Act 2004 was to ban the hunting of wild mammals with dogs in England and Wales. The Act made it an offence to hunt a wild mammal with a dog, except in limited circumstances. The intention of the House of Commons in relation to this key aim was multifaceted, combining concerns over animal welfare with a constitutional objective of asserting the primacy of the elected chamber.
The primary intention of the House of Commons was to address what a majority of its members considered to be a cruel and inhumane activity. The debate over fox hunting had been a long-running and divisive political issue. Those MPs in favour of a ban argued that the chasing and killing of animals such as foxes, deer, and hares by packs of hounds caused unnecessary and unjustifiable suffering (House of Commons Library, 2016). This position was presented as a matter of public morality and animal welfare. The vote on the issue was treated as a matter of conscience for MPs, and successive votes in the Commons demonstrated a large and consistent majority in favour of an outright ban (Cowley, 2005). Therefore, the central aim was to legislate to end a practice that was deemed ethically unacceptable by the elected representatives of the people.
A further intention of the House of Commons was to reflect and enforce public opinion on the matter. Although hunting was an activity undertaken by a minority, it was an issue that attracted significant public interest. Proponents of the ban consistently referred to opinion polls that suggested a majority of the public was opposed to hunting with dogs (House of Commons Library, 2016). In this context, the House of Commons saw itself as having a democratic responsibility to act on this expression of public will, even though the subject was not a major manifesto commitment. The intention was to align the law with the perceived moral view of the wider population.
Finally, the decision to use the Parliament Acts to enact the legislation reveals a clear constitutional intention. The bill to ban hunting was repeatedly passed by the House of Commons but was consistently rejected or amended to the point of unacceptability by the House of Lords. The Lords was seen by many in the Commons as representing traditional, rural, and landed interests which were resistant to the reform (Russell, 2005). The persistence of the House of Commons, and its eventual resort to the Parliament Acts, was therefore an assertion of its democratic legitimacy and constitutional supremacy over the unelected second chamber. The intention was not only to achieve the policy aim of banning hunting but also to ensure that the determined will of the elected House could not be frustrated by the House of Lords. The enactment of the Hunting Act 2004 was thus a clear demonstration of the ultimate power residing with the Commons in the UK’s legislative process.
In conclusion, this assignment has explained that a Public Act is a statute of general application, whereas a Private Act is one of a specific or local application. Examples of each type of Act from both the twentieth and twenty first centuries have been identified. The assignment then selected the Hunting Act 2004, a Public Act passed under the Parliament Acts 1911 and 1949. An analysis was undertaken of the intention of the House of Commons in relation to the Act’s key aim of banning hunting with dogs. This analysis showed that the Commons’ intention was principally driven by concerns over animal welfare, a desire to reflect public opinion, and a constitutional determination to assert its legislative primacy over the House of Lords.
References
- Bradley, A.W., Ewing, K.D. and Knight, C.J.S. (2018) Constitutional and Administrative Law. 17th edn. Harlow: Pearson Education.
- Cowley, P. (2005) The Hunting Bill. In: P. Cowley (ed.) The Rebels: How Blair Mislaid His Majority. London: Politico’s Publishing, pp. 119-140.
- Equality Act 2010, c. 15.
- Highgate Cemetery Act 2022, c. i.
- House of Commons Library (2016) The Hunting Act 2004. Briefing Paper, Number 00293.
- Human Rights Act 1998, c. 42.
- Hunting Act 2004, c. 37.
- Loveland, I. (2021) Constitutional Law, Administrative Law, and Human Rights: A Critical Introduction. 9th edn. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
- Parliament Act 1911, c. 13.
- Parliament Act 1949, c. 103.
- Russell, M. (2005) ‘The Hunting Act: A Case Study in Legislative Scrutiny and Executive Control’, Parliamentary Affairs, 58(3), pp. 656–665.
- University College London Act 1996, c. iii.

