SEE LATEST ESSAYS Tort law

Critically evaluate whether there should be a Good Samaritan law in England and Wales

Law Writer
November 01, 2026
No comments
Tort law - image of person having been hit by a car, lying on the floor

This essay is a sample of our Basic AI essay writer (Undergraduate 2:2 standard).

For guaranteed 2:1, First Class and Masters-level essays, register and top up your wallet.

Section 1: Introduction

The common law of England and Wales has traditionally rejected the idea of a general duty to rescue, often illustrated by the stark 'drowning child' analogy where an onlooker can, without legal repercussion, watch a child drown in a shallow pool. This position reflects a core legal principle that the law does not typically penalise omissions. A 'Good Samaritan' law would directly oppose this by creating a legal duty for individuals to offer reasonable assistance to those in peril. This essay will argue that while the absence of a general duty may appear morally questionable, the current legal framework in England and Wales should be maintained. It will be contended that the strong judicial rationale favouring individual liberty, as explored in cases like Stovin v Wise [1996] AC 923, provides a compelling argument against compulsory altruism. Furthermore, the established exceptions to the general rule, which impose a duty to act in specific circumstances based on relationships or an assumption of responsibility, already provide adequate protection for the vulnerable. Therefore, the current law strikes a workable and appropriate balance between preserving individual freedom and enforcing duties where it is just and reasonable to do so.

Section 2: Skeleton Essay Plan

  • The General Rule: No Liability for Omissions and the Protection of Individual Liberty
  • The starting point in English law (both criminal and tort) is that there is no general duty to act to prevent harm. An omission, or a failure to act, is not typically a basis for liability.
  • This principle is founded on the philosophical value of individual autonomy and liberty. The law is hesitant to compel a person to act, as this is seen as a significant infringement on their freedom. As Lord Hoffmann noted, it is less of an invasion of freedom to be told what you are not allowed to do than to be told what you must do.
  • Key Case: Smith v Littlewoods Organisation Ltd [1987] AC 241. This case in tort law confirmed the general reluctance to impose liability for an omission, specifically for failing to prevent a third party from causing damage. Lord Goff stated there is no "general duty to prevent others (third parties) from causing damage". This reinforces the idea that individuals are not expected to be their 'brother's keeper'.
  • Judicial Rationale and Policy Arguments Against a General Duty to Rescue
  • The judiciary has provided clear policy reasons for resisting the imposition of a general duty to act. These go beyond the simple 'individual liberty' argument.
  • Key Case: Stovin v Wise [1996] AC 923. Lord Hoffmann’s judgment is central to understanding this reluctance. He raised several issues:
  • The ‘Why pick on me?’ argument: It can be difficult to identify who, in a group of onlookers, should bear the duty to act. The law prefers duties to be certain.
  • Defining the scope of the duty: It would be difficult to legislate the standard of the required intervention. How much risk must a rescuer undertake? What level of skill is required? This creates legal uncertainty.
  • Economic and political arguments: Forcing a person to act for the benefit of another is akin to imposing a form of uncompensated labour. Lord Hoffmann described it as "a duty to confer a benefit upon a stranger" which sits uneasily with the principles of common law.
  • The Adequacy of the Existing Exceptions to the General Rule
  • The argument that there is a complete absence of a duty to act is incorrect. The common law has developed several well-established exceptions where a failure to act can result in legal liability. This demonstrates that the law is not blind to moral obligations where a specific relationship or situation justifies it.
  • These exceptions provide a targeted approach, imposing duties only where there is a clear basis for doing so, unlike a blanket 'Good Samaritan' law.
  • Categories of Exceptions:
  • Special Relationship: A duty is owed between individuals who have a special relationship, such as parent and child.
  • Key Case: R v Gibbins and Proctor (1918) 13 Cr App R 134, where a father and his partner were convicted of murder for deliberately starving the father's child. Their relationship to the child created a clear duty to provide food and care.
  • Voluntary Assumption of Responsibility: Where an individual voluntarily assumes responsibility for another's welfare, a duty of care is created.
  • Key Case: R v Stone and Dobinson [1977] QB 354, where a couple who took in an infirm relative were found liable for her death when they failed to care for her or summon help.
  • Creation of a Dangerous Situation: If a person creates a dangerous situation, they are under a duty to take reasonable steps to avert that danger.
  • Key Case: R v Miller [1983] 2 AC 161, where a squatter who accidentally started a fire and then failed to do anything about it was convicted of arson.
  • Conclusion: The Current Law Provides a Superior Balance
  • A general Good Samaritan law, while well-intentioned, would create significant legal uncertainty and represent a substantial infringement on individual liberty.
  • The practical problems identified in Stovin v Wise concerning the scope and incidence of the duty remain persuasive.
  • The current framework of English law provides a more nuanced and just approach. It upholds the principle of individual autonomy as a general rule but carves out specific, justifiable exceptions.
  • These exceptions ensure that duties are imposed on those who, because of their relationship, their undertakings, or their own actions, can fairly be expected to act. This targeted approach effectively protects the vulnerable without creating an overly burdensome and ill-defined duty on the general public.

References

  • Horsey, K. and Rackley, E. (2021) Tort Law. 7th edn. Oxford University Press.
  • R v Gibbins and Proctor (1918) 13 Cr App R 134.
  • R v Miller [1983] 2 AC 161.
  • R v Stone and Dobinson [1977] QB 354.
  • Smith v Littlewoods Organisation Ltd [1987] AC 241.
  • Stovin v Wise [1996] AC 923.

Rate this essay:

How useful was this post?

Click on a star to rate it!

Average rating 0 / 5. Vote count: 0

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this post.

Written By

Law Writer

Recent essays:

Advice for Mick regarding his rights under the Sale of Goods Act 1893

This advice will address the legal position of Mick concerning his purchase of a Ford Fiesta from Dodgy Derek, a car dealer. The central ...
Read more: Advice for Mick regarding his rights under the Sale of Goods Act 1893

Gillespie and Weare note that ‘Statutes are Acts of Parliament and are either Public Acts … or Private Acts …’. Explain what a Public Act is and explain what a Private Act is and identify two examples of each of these two types of Primary Legislation. One of the identified examples of a Public Act should be one that was enacted in the twentieth century and the other should be one that was enacted in the twenty first century. One of the identified examples of a Private Act should be one that was enacted in the twentieth century and the other should be one that was enacted in the twenty first century. Select one Public Act that was passed using the Parliament Acts (of 1911 and 1949). Analyse the intention of the House of Commons in relation to the key aim to be achieved by the enactment of the Act that you have selected. Note: The Act that you select should be a different one from the two identified examples referred to in the paragraph above.

This assignment will explain the two main types of primary legislation enacted by the Parliament of the United Kingdom, which are Public Acts and ...
Read more: Gillespie and Weare note that ‘Statutes are Acts of Parliament and are either Public Acts … or Private Acts …’. Explain what a Public Act is and explain what a Private Act is and identify two examples of each of these two types of Primary Legislation. One of the identified examples of a Public Act should be one that was enacted in the twentieth century and the other should be one that was enacted in the twenty first century. One of the identified examples of a Private Act should be one that was enacted in the twentieth century and the other should be one that was enacted in the twenty first century. Select one Public Act that was passed using the Parliament Acts (of 1911 and 1949). Analyse the intention of the House of Commons in relation to the key aim to be achieved by the enactment of the Act that you have selected. Note: The Act that you select should be a different one from the two identified examples referred to in the paragraph above.

Permission to approach the inbox?

Helpful legal writing guidance, AI updates, free credits and exclusive offers, delivered occasionally and respectfully. No spam, no waffle, no abuse of process.